OrgPad logo

From heat wave mitigation in urban environment to global water cycle restoration

Created by Tomas Kalisz

Should the proposed practical experiments with installation of solar panels cooled by water evaporation i cities and urban / industrial landscapes prove that this concept is harmless for the environment, the next step may be expansion of such solar facilities into arid landscapes, enabled by cooling thereof cooled with sea water evaporation. There are hints that such concept might exhibit a synergy in climate change mitigation, by combining (i) "decarbonization" of the electricity production by massive solar energy exploitation with (ii) water cycle restoration in arid landscapes, enabling the desired non-radiative cooling therein.

#climate modelling, #desert cooling, #evapotranspiration, #heat islands, #heat waves, #sea water exploitation for solar cell cooling, #solar cell cooling, #solar energy, #sustainable electricity production, #water cycle

From heat wave mitigation in urban environment to global water cycle restoration

..or at least some role

jcliD1300163 757..768 (washington.edu)

Contrary to a widely spread view..

atmospheric concentration of greenhouse gases is NOT the sole parameter decisive for Earth surface temperature

Of course, assuming that other parameters usually considered in the energy balance, like solar radiation, Earth surface albedo etc., remain stable (constant).

because a fit between theory and reality requires stepping beyond the radiative greenhouse effect model

Available models do not appear to be capable of a reliable prediction..

..however, seem to suggest that water cycle plays an important role in Earth temperature regulation

The attached preprint was retrieved on December 24, 2022 from: https://esd.copernicus.org/preprints/esd-2022-5/esd-2022-5.pdf

 

esd-2022-5_modely_non-radiative-cooling.pdf

Access to published final text

https://researchportal.vub.be/en/publications/the-biogeophysical-effects-of-idealized-land-cover-and-land-manag

https://cris.vub.be/ws/portalfiles/portal/88409508/DeHertog_etal_2022_ESD.pdf

this circumstance might be exploited for mitigating the effect of non-condensing greenhouse gases

retrospective modelling of a global aforestation / deforestation supports this view

https://researchportal.vub.be/en/publications/global-forestation-and-deforestation-affect-remote-climate-via-ad

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33279-9

(open Access)

so far, the models assume a fixed temperature profile?

arXiv:2301.09998

Therefore, in the models,global warming resulting from the loss of transpirational cooling is, for the same deforested area, at least one order of magni-tude smaller than our estimate (Table 1). 

see page 8, penultimate paragraph + page 10, first paragraph:

In current models, it is assumed that as the planet warms, the temperature lapse rate should slightly diminish followingmoist adiabat (the so-called lapse rate feedback, Sejas et al., 2021). This robust model feature is not, however, supportedby observations (Fig. 5). Satellite data are consistent with an increase in the lapse rate (Fig. 5). The temperature differencebetween the surface and the upper radiatve layer ze (located between 500 and 400 mb, Benestad, 2017) grows at approximatelythe same rate as the surface temperature itself. This effect is especially pronounced over land (Fig. 5c,f). This is consistent witha radiative forcing imposed by changing non-radiative fluxes, including those due to the land cover change (Fig. 3d-f).2301.09998_Makarieva_et_al_20230124.pdf

non-radiative surface cooling as a mitigation mechanism

Purely radiative greenhouse effect, with no other mechanism of heat transfer from the surface into atmosphere, results in maximal possible difference between surface temperature and cover temperature. Contact of the cover (atmosphere) with the surface, enabling also heat transfer by hot air convection and by water evaporation from the surface and condensation thereof in the atmosphere, enables lower surface temperatures as radiative cooling alone and thus reduces the difference between the surface temperature and cover temperature (makes cooling of the surface more efficient and the greenhouse effect less powerful):

grafik

radiative greenhouse effect theory

Hartmann, Physical climatology, 2016:

Model of a thin glass plate separated from the Earth surface by vacuum:

grafik

..and sea water instead of scarce fresh water in arid areas

Once the destroyed water cycle is successfully restarted with external water supply..

By exploiting evapotranspiration

..using evaporatively cooled solar cells as a surrogate for trees

..planting trees can follow..

How can we keep an insolated landscape pleasant?

..with a more reasonable chance..

low efficiency

Semiconductor physics implies that solar cell efficiency decreases with teperature of the p-n junction included in the cell.

Lot of waste heat produced

In form of dry hot air

or might it perhaps make deserts green again?

A model suggests that lot of excessive dry hot air created by solar installation in Sahara desert might bring rain thereto.

 

Another model asserts the same conlusion for deserts along to Red Sea.

..that a stable green plant cover forms and a more human-friendly ecosystem will establish

Low cost

Simplicity

Cons

might worsen "heat island" phenomenon?

experimentally

by practical comparison on a small scale

design an urban experiment?

Estalished technology

Pros:

Classical ("dry")

Currently, photovoltaic cells used for direct solar energy coversion into electricity are passively cooled by radiation + air convection.

passive air cooling

Ideally both in parallel!

the experiment could validate which models do fit with reality

along with more reliable hints whether or not a massive use of solar technology can pose an environmental risks

The difference may have consequences for climate

depending on what is true

crucial information whether or not it can make a sense to develop the alternative solar technology can be obtained

we can check/prove it

Solar cell technology

might cool urban landscapes?

theoretically

by modelling

start a modelling project?

Commercially unavailable yet

Alternative ("wet")

One of the oldest and simplest means for an effective cooling is making the cooled object wet and ensure an efficient air convention around the object. Heat created in the object converts into latent heat of water vapour.

Vaporization of 1 kg water consumes ca 2257 kJ (0.627 kWh) energy.

 

evaporative active cooling

Cons:

Pros:

In form of latent heat of water vapor

Higher cost

Complexity

higher efficiency

might act as a substitute for "biotic pump"?

The biotic pump hypothesis asserts that water evapotranspiration by terrestrial vegetation, enhancing the small water cycle, may play a crucial role for water transport from ocean to land and thus for functionality of the entire "big" water cycle.

But still significant waste heat produced

video: jan Pokorný, Anastassia Makarieva

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxEwJYNb_zA